Skip to main content

Forgive but don't Forget - Thomas Szasz - Know when to speak

The stupid neither forgive nor forget; the naive forgive and forget; the wise forgive but do not forget.

Quote from Thomas Szasz,  Psychiatrist, Advocate for patients' rights, Manifesto creator  (Materials in this post reproduced with the permission of Jeffrey A. Schaler.  All rights reserved.).



The other day I was talking to a student about how some people don't like that others remember things.  We both ended up laughing because I was trying to remember Szasz's quote and I couldn't.  Double funny in that the quote was about remembering and what wise people remember.


Anyway, I do remember a coworker telling me that one of the bosses didn't like that I don't forget.  

I do not think that this is the issue.  The boss was extremely intelligent and he also didn't forget.  I do think there are multiple other issues going on.

The boss didn't like to be reminded of things he didn't like to remember.  Oiy, isn't that all of us!  The key word in that sentence is "reminded."  

Another issue is that I inartfully and without consideration of the consequences bring up past events.  I "didn't read the room" with enough skill.

This came up once because I gave the boss some advice to make someone happy.  A moneyless way to demonstrate that another employee was valued.  The boss liked the idea and followed through with it and the person was appreciative.  

Later, for a purely economic reason, the boss had to rescind this "boon" and replace it with another one.  The employee expressed a certain level of dissatisfaction.  The boss replayed the events to me and expressed how he didn't was unhappy with me.  I ignored his tone and suggested that maybe if he had explained the economics behind the decision, the employee would have understood.  The boss said, "Well, maybe I should talk to you about supersensitive employees."  

The impression I got is that since I am super-sensitive, I could give insight. Hmmm.  That I had a logic-based response was irrelevant.  I had misread the room and actually I did not have the skill (and probably now still do not have the skill) to handle giving a suggestion in that type of situation.  

Which is my point.  Never forgetting is not the issue.  The issue is how information is presented to the intended audience.  Of course, Dr. Szasz's quote does not address what to do with the information that "wise" people do not forget.

Which leads to another quote:  

It is better to remain silent at the risk of being thought a fool, than to talk and remove all doubt of it.

This one is from Maurice Switzer from 1906.  The provenance of this phrase is explored in the wonderful blog Quote Investigator which dives into how this has been misattributed and paraphrased by others, including Lincoln and Twain.



Gratitudes:  Ink cartridge refills, Tile, dust-busters.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Never Lose Enthusiasm - Aldous Huxley - Secret of Genius

The secret of genius is to carry the spirit of the child into old age, which means never losing your enthusiasm. attributed to:  Aldous Huxley First, I am a little uncomfortable with using this quote.  Normally, I research the origin of a quote for assurances of correctness.  However, after ten minutes of weeding through google results of pinterest, twitter, and the huge quotation cites, I could not find the context of this quote nor conformation that it was Huxley.  Sigh.   If any of my gentle readers have the citation and context of this quote, it would be greatly appreciated.   Second, I decided just to get on with the blog.  What is important?  Spending time verifying a quote (which is not the main purpose of the blog) or crystallizing my idea in writing.  And then to get on living life.   Enthusiasm.  This is what attracted me to this quote.  When things were dark for me, I didn't even have the en...

What can I change? - Leo Tolstoy via The Artist's Way -

Everyone thinks of changing the world, but no one thinks of changing himself. Widely attributed to Leo Tolstoi (or Tolstoy):   Author , Activist .  Another misquote.  Sigh.  The above quote is actually from  The Artist's Way at Work : Riding the Dragon  (1999) The actual Tolstoi quote is:   There can be only one permanent revolution — a moral one; the regeneration of the inner man. How is this revolution to take place? Nobody knows how it will take place in humanity, but every man feels it clearly in himself. And yet in our world everybody thinks of changing humanity, and nobody thinks of changing himself. Now, don't get me wrong.  I love the The Artist's Way.  I journal three pages every morning (fingers crossed).  And since Tolstoi wrote in Russian, maybe The Artist's Way translation is accurate.   Anyway.  Today's blog entry is about change.  I was writing in my journal all of the bitchi...

Don't trust a skinny cook - Vinne Vrotny - Teacher Hypocrisy

Adults want comfort, but expect students to go into [the] discomfort zone.  Are we hypocrites?  from Vinnie Vrotny - Blog post    Multi-faceted Refractions I live with the thought that I am a hypocrite.  I am a teacher almost every day I implore, cajole, push, and pull students to learn more about the immediate subject and themselves.  And yet I feel guilty when I don't do the same thing. To find today's quote, I Googled "quotes teacher hypocrisy" and got no love.  I got quotes from Don King, Malcom X, Alan Dershowitz (black pot) and others.  But no listed, no famous quotes about teachers and hypocrisy.   Then I Googled "teacher hypocrisy" and oh boy, were there hits!.   Grass roots education ;  Condor Voice ; I, Hypocrite Teache r; and today's quote were just a start.   I realized that I am not alone.   I must admit I also hate lazy teachers.  They...